Skip to main content

Judging Bush's foreign policy - and Obama's

Steve Walt issued a 14-point indictment of George W. Bush's foreign policy, and Will Inboden issued a response. Both are found in Foreign Policy's website .

Like Imboden, I think Walt is wrong to say Bush should have done more about Bin Laden before 9/11. That is a case of hindsight and wishful thinking. Every disaster is followed by a chorus of "we should have known better."

I also think Bush should get some credit for the lack of a major terrorist attack against the U.S. after 9/11. But some perspective is also needed. Bin Laden and his network were dangerous, but they were not as rich or as powerful as many small nations. The U.S. should not brag about preventing Libya or Khazakstan from mounting serious attacks on the U.S. But if an aggressive Libya or Khazakstan dominates our foreign policy for a decade, we should be embarassed. That is what happened with Al Queda.

Bush's foreign policy was a disaster for one reason: He started an unnecessary war in Iraq. Even Bush's public reasons for beginning that war (WMD and Iraqi links to Al Queda) were not sufficient reasons to go to war. His public reasons turned out to be illusions (ie, he saw what he wanted to see). Bush's real reason for going to war (re-making the map of the Middle East) was a pipe dream. The war has cost lives and immense treasure. The real cost, though, was the cost it exacted on all other foreign policy objectives.

The pragmatic difficulty of carrying on two major military interventions left us with little leverage in the rest of the world. Other bad foreign policy news during the Bush administration (Russia's growing influence on its neighbors, lack of progress in the Middle East, North Korea's assertiveness, and Iran's assertiveness) was a result of the opening created by our preoccupation with two wars. One of the most unreported aspects of Iran's foreign policy is that they could not be so bold if Saddam Hussein, their mortal enemy, was still on their border.

Imboden says it was important for Bush to 'narrow' the anti-terror effort to a "war on terror" so that Muslims would not feel targeted. Imboden wears the same blinders that Bush did. Bush should have narrowed the effort much further by declaring war only on Al Queda. Nobody thinks Muslims were impressed with Bush's choice of phrases but forgot that Bush invaded two Muslim nations.

A history with no invasion of Iraq would have permitted success in Afganistan. Some of the effort that has poured into the Iraqi quagmire could have been used to bolster our alliances with important regional (Muslim) players like Turkey. And a more successful Afganistan would mean a more stable Pakistan.

Imboden also defends Bush by stating that Obama has continued many of Bush's policies. This is Imboden's most naive statement. Obama did not have the option to make the Iraq occupation disappear, or to go back in time and focus on Afganistan, or to undo the momentum Iran, Russia, and North Korea have enjoyed while the U.S. was distracted.

Obama's options in foreign policy were very limited. Had he abruptly made changes, it would have been wreckless--he might have even been accused of cowboy diplomacy. Obama is more pragmatic. Foreign policy requires time and intelligence.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Deferred Maintenance

I once worked at a public university that had a huge 'deferred maintenance' problem. Their major equipment was often 35 years old with an expected lifetime of 30 years. As a result, they were constantly doing repairs and paying overtime, but had little time to do preventive maintenance and little money to make pro-active investments in new equipment. In one dorm, water from bad showers on the upper floors started leaking into the main lobby, and the 'fix' was to drag out garbage cans to catch the water. I was told that repairing the plumbing itself was expensive so it was being figured into the "five-year budget plan." The garbage can fix went on for at least a year. A two-page spread in The Atlantic Monthly (March 2008, p 38-39) calls out our nation's growing infrastructure problem. This is a real 'tragedy of the commons' situation: individuals are not willing to give up more tax money if they don't see a real-time, personal benefit. At the sa...

Whose fault are high gas prices?

GM recently announced the closing of several auto plants in North America, primarily those that make large, gas inefficient vehicles. The news anchor began the segment with "Due to high gas prices..." Since everyone's blaming high gas prices for our woes these days, it begs the question "Whose fault are high gas prices?" Your driveway is the first place to look for answers. If your car gets bad mileage, that's probably your fault. Some luck, huh? After that, I blame "the invisible hand." This is the idea that when everyone follows their own self-interest in a free market, everyone ends up better off. Everyone is motivated to work hard and be efficient and produce goods that others want to trade for. Free markets do a fine job of producing wealth and prosperity, but they've really botched the energy situation. For all it's glory, the invisible hand has little strategic foresight. In the 1970s, we learned that America was vulnerable to high e...

Real Estate in America

We sold our house this summer and bought a new home. The experience has led me to reflect on homes and home-buying in America. As in any industry, there are good and bad incentives at work in real estate. A home seller would like to get the highest price for their house and sell it in a reasonable period of time. The industry operates on a commission system so that the agent seeks to sell the house at a higher price. This incentive works, but only to a point. Consider the impact of $5000 on the seller vs. the agent. Six percent of $5000 is $300. After the realty company and purchasing agent take their cut, the agent isn't left with much. A $5000 difference in the price of the house means little to the agent, but a lot to the home owner. Does an agent become successful by getting the highest price or by turning over lots of houses? The answer is obvious. An agent's ideal world is not one where people get exactly the right price for their homes, it is a world where everyone is wi...