Skip to main content

Posts

The American Sorta, Maybe, Sometimes Right to Vote

I posted Voter Fraud a decade ago, when Wisconsin passed a Voter ID law. That article holds up pretty well today. Sadly, voter suppression efforts have also held up quite well. It’s time for an update, plus some commentary on a discussion I saw. First, I need to correct an error in my older post, where I referred to the “Constitutional right to vote”. Alas, the Constitution contains no right to vote! While our Founding Fathers did a lot of things pretty well, they didn’t bother to guarantee the vote. It’s a difficult right to guarantee, as it does require some agency on the part of the voter, and voter agency is something you cannot guarantee. The Founding Fathers could still have done better than they did. They couldn't commit to a right to vote when they wanted more people kept out of the ballot box than allowed inside. This initial error led successive generations to fix the Constitutional “sorta maybe right to vote” with amendments. But like a roof, patching up a Constitution...

Federal incompetence is an equilibrium strategy

I’ve heard a number of commentators--right, left, and center--characterize Trump as the pivotal problem with Republican leadership. But why was Trump overwhelming to the Republican party? Why was he gradually embraced by nearly all Republican leadership? And would the Republican party be much different today without him? Each party is made up of different interest groups. Two large factions of the Republican Party are fiscal conservatives and the Christian Right. The fiscal conservatives are dominated by Free Market Fundamentalists. Anti-tax pledges and opposition to virtually any government regulations are Free Market Fundamentalist positions, and those positions are prominent in the current Republican party. The Christian Right wants white Christian conservative values to dominate American culture. They once did dominate American culture, and they want to turn back the clock. These two influential factions of the Republican party do not make natural teammates. Free Market Fundamental...

A peak at Joe Biden's character from 25 years ago

Twenty-five years ago, I got a glimpse of Joe Biden's character. I think it’s beautiful and want to share it. When I was youn ger and wanted to kick back and relax, I would, of course, watch C-SPAN. What can I say? I was pretty cool. There was still some political grandstanding 25 years ago, but in those days Congresspeople sometimes actually tried to convince each other of things. It wasn’t just canned talking points. One day I saw Senator Joe Biden give a talk on the Senate floor. This was almost exactly 25 years ago. After I watched his talk, I had two thoughts: Why can’t a guy like this be President? He’s wearing his heart on his sleeve in this talk, and that kind of thing does not get you to the Presidency. So.. what was he talking about? This was after the fall of the Berlin wall and the disintegration of the USSR. The former country of Yugoslavia had essentially broken apart into smaller districts, and violence broke out along ethnic and religious lines. Biden had been to t...

Beautiful rants

This rant is making the rounds on the internet. The sentiment of the rant seems to be weariness with political and social conflict. Hey, I get it. I was born weary. But what is this rant really calling for? It markets itself as a centrist plea for compassion and community. I think it has a clear political slant and is more of a call for nihilism and disengagement. You decide. Here’s the rant. Afterwards, I’ll comment and go on a rant of my own. Here’s a warning: I have a little fun with my commentary and get a little snarky. If you don’t want to see that, hit your back button and move on with life. <> I don’t know who wrote this but SOMEONE FINALLY put into words what many of us have been thinking and I couldn't agree more! I’m tired of covid-19. I’m tired of blacks vs. whites. I’m tired of Democrats vs. Republicans. I’m REALLY tired of the media. I’m really tired of the wearing a mask debate. I’m tired of no one being allowed to think what they want & how they feel witho...

The assault on democracy won't end here

The philosophy of history that I was taught growing up could be best described as American Constitutional Hubris. That’s been the focus of history classrooms since World War 2. I was taught that there have been good ideas in history and bad ideas. Our ideas are the good ones, and that’s why we won. It’s never been that simple. There are strengths and weaknesses in Democracy, Republicanism, Capitalism, Socialism, Fascism, Communism, and all the rest. Each is vulnerable to evil in different ways. Most of the movements we think of as Fascist or Communist or Socialist or Democratic were themselves conglomerations of different ideas, none of them as purely good or evil as we like to think. The evil aspects of these ideas can evolve. They latch on to more noble ideas and twist them. Our own Constitutional Democracy is not as immune to this type of corruption as we like to think. Our naivety on that point is dangerous. Evil ideas assaulted our democracy head-on during World War II and the Col...

Bending truth as a habit had consequences

Our democracy is not only reliant on the words of the Constitution. It is reliant on countless rules and norms that have persisted through generations. When people in governance decide they must win at all costs, those rules and norms become loopholes for political advantage. It does not violate the letter of the laws of democracy, but it is undemocratic. Abusing the rules of governance  is an undemocratic method to achieve political victory. It is the theft of political power from people. When the people of a state elect a governor, they expect him or her to have the powers of the governor. In at least a couple examples, state legislatures have rushed to strip power from the office of the governor after elections because their party did not win. In Wisconsin, the leader of the legislature said this was necessary because the incoming governor “could not be trusted”, despite the obvious fact that the incoming governor had been elected by a majority of voters in the state. This is an...

The political parties are NOT mirror images of each other

America has changed over time. There were some strange forces that held us together, and kept power from being concentrated. Those forces have faded. Resources can be concentrated more easily, and the political parties have less in common. (For that story, read the prior three posts.) As should be expected, each party has made strategic choices in response to those changes, and each choice influences the choices that come later. Both parties have contributed to American greatness. Both parties have great ideas to offer. Both parties have some bad actors. Both parties “play the game”. But one party made a choice that sent it down a more undemocratic path.  It's not because people are bad or crazy. But each choice leads to the choices that come later. Let’s look at five [5] examples of undemocratic practices. Before I begin, let me be clear. I'm not  confusing democracy with our democratic republic. I understand we’re not an absolute democracy. When I say “undemocratic”, I mean ...