Skip to main content

Bad memes: This meme makes me happy



This Harden/Jordan meme makes me so happy. It is a classic illustration of a meme, and it is a classic illustration of propaganda. Memes are teeny blips in the broader world of propaganda, but they are simple and direct examples of propaganda.


Propaganda is designed to bypass rational thought. It triggers emotional responses before we have a chance to think things through. When our emotional systems have already been pushed in one direction or another, our thinking systems almost always follow in the same direction.


Memes go straight for our emotions. Look at the Harden/Jordan meme. The Jordan picture shows an intricate, difficult task--Jordan with both hands on the ball, and the defenders swarm around him--arms up, eyes up.


The Harden picture is the opposite--two clowns could not do a better job of mocking a basketball moment. The defender leans in awkwardly, hoping to draw a charge. Harden flails, appearing to look straight up in the air as he begins his shot.


It is well-designed to push your emotions in a direction. It suggests that the NBA was once glorious, but is now silly. The meme doesn’t want you to think; it only wants to engage your emotion and then leave before rational thought enters the frame. The old NBA is glorious and the new NBA is comical; now move on before you start to think.


But let’s be rational for just a moment. Someone browsed a thousand pictures of the modern NBA and used the silliest picture they could find. They browsed a thousand pictures of the NBA in the 90’s and used the most noble picture they could find. There are tens of thousands of pictures from each era to choose from.


Someone could very easily create the opposite effect with an awkward picture from the old NBA and an elegant picture from today’s NBA. The rational case for comparing the eras doesn't matter next to the emotional images. Memes go straight for your emotion.


Such is propaganda. It seems obvious to me when I look at the Harden/Jordan meme, and that’s why it makes me happy.





This protest meme is exactly the same thing. Exactly the same thing! The contrast between an old noble protest and a the chaotic looting of a Target hits our limbic system directly.


A determined person could find plenty of pictures of riots during the Civil Rights movement. You can find plenty of noble pictures from the George Floyd protests. But wait--rational thought is not allowed. Meme propaganda is about scoring easy points.


If points are easy to score, they must not have any impact, right? Unfortunately, the points have an impact. There’s a principle called social proof. One of our human default settings is to respect something more if more people are doing it, saying it, or supporting it. If one person in a crowd is staring up, who cares? But if half the people are staring up, there must be something to see.


Meme propaganda serves as social proof to keep members of a group from serious consideration of other viewpoints. They are a constant reminder about whose team you are on.


They are a also subversive. They don’t only remind you not to consider opposing viewpoints. They typically include some form of mockery or disgust that serve to suppress empathy. The clownish picture of James Harden’s bad shot is mockery. The chaotic picture of looters is intended to trigger disgust. Both suggest that there is no rational defense for an opposing viewpoint.


Mockery and disgust suppress empathy. Empathy is the most noble, most Christian of human emotions. Don't leave empathy behind.





***

[Note: Any memes shared actually crossed my Facebook feed. I did not go looking for them. They came looking for me.]


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Real Estate in America

We sold our house this summer and bought a new home. The experience has led me to reflect on homes and home-buying in America. As in any industry, there are good and bad incentives at work in real estate. A home seller would like to get the highest price for their house and sell it in a reasonable period of time. The industry operates on a commission system so that the agent seeks to sell the house at a higher price. This incentive works, but only to a point. Consider the impact of $5000 on the seller vs. the agent. Six percent of $5000 is $300. After the realty company and purchasing agent take their cut, the agent isn't left with much. A $5000 difference in the price of the house means little to the agent, but a lot to the home owner. Does an agent become successful by getting the highest price or by turning over lots of houses? The answer is obvious. An agent's ideal world is not one where people get exactly the right price for their homes, it is a world where everyone is wi...

The 2020 Vote: Bending toward justice

The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.  --  Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. My hero, Dr. King, was wrong about justice. I love Dr. King. His writings and speeches are collected in a book called “A Testament of Hope”. That book was a revelation for me. Dr. King had a moral clarity that is rare in this world. Many of his observations were accurate, wise, and timeless. But the ‘arc of the moral universe’ statement is misleading. We are promised no such experience in this world. In Dr. King’s time, the quote may have been both accurate and wise. King saw the expanding reach of national newspapers and television networks. When the nation, through that new media, was exposed to the reality and brutality of overt Southern racism--then the nation, which believed it shared a common and decent morality, imposed that morality on the South. While Dr. King’s understanding may have been both accurate and wise, it was not timeless. This is where my moral hero comes u...

Support Ukraine: contact your representatives.

Congress has held up another support package to Ukraine. The simple fact that the aid package has been delayed is a win for Putin’s authoritarian regime. I’ll start with what you should do, then a little about why, then address some objections to Ukraine aid. What you should do Please contact your Senators and Representatives to the US Congress and ask them to support Ukraine aid. Find them here . The US government, acting on behalf of US citizens, can do things that individuals just can’t do. That’s why contacting your elected officials is important. I also encourage you to contribute regularly to alleviate the ongoing suffering Russia causes. Here are some I have supported: Lutheran Disaster Response, Eastern European Crisis Fund , which supports Ukraine and Ukrainian refugees who have fled to nearby countries. Razom For Ukraine , which supports Ukraine in a variety of ways, which can include supplies for civilians or troops (but not weapons). Safe Skies , which raises money for rada...